In an initial win for several Virginia school boards, an Arlington judge has granted their request to continue requiring students and staff to wear masks in schools until a final ruling is made in the matter.
Circuit Court Judge Louise DiMatteo on Friday granted seven school districts, including five in Northern Virginia, a temporary restraining order against Gov. Glenn Youngkin's executive order declaring parents can decide whether their children wear masks to school. DiMatteo ruled that the case rests on the issue of authority and she found Youngkin’s order can’t override school district policy.
"The order allows schools to continue to protect the health and well-being of all students and staff. While the legal process on this matter continues, today’s ruling preserves the existing policies and practices in Virginia school divisions, which includes masking requirements," the school boards said in a joint statement after the ruling.
We've got the news you need to know to start your day. Sign up for the First & 4Most morning newsletter — delivered to your inbox daily. Sign up here.
A spokesperson for Youngkin said in a statement his administration would appeal the decision.
"The governor will never stop fighting for parents’ ability to choose what is best for their children. The governor often said that this is not a pro-mask or anti-mask debate. It’s about parents knowing what’s best for their child’s health, and opting-out should there be a mask mandate," the spokesperson said in part.
The ruling comes as emotions continue to run high in schools, with parents in favor of masking fearful that the governor’s order endangers their children, and parents against masking angry that some Northern Virginia school districts are isolating or suspending students who don't wear masks.
DiMatteo, who covers Arlington County and the City of Falls Church, said as she heard arguments last week, “I’m not here to decide who is right and wrong on masking. This case is a question of who has authority.”
Youngkin issued Executive Order 2 on his first day in office, declaring that starting Jan. 24, families could opt out of mask mandates at K-12 schools. The Republican former business executive promised a new approach to the pandemic, emphasizing personal choice.
Five Northern Virginia school districts plus two others in the state filed a lawsuit the day Youngkin’s executive order took effect. The school boards of Alexandria City, Arlington County, the City of Richmond, Fairfax County, Falls Church City, Hampton City and Prince William County argued the state constitution gives local school boards the authority to run their districts. They cited a state law that requires school systems to follow federal health guidelines, which include recommendations for universal masking.
"Prior to today’s decision, Virginia school boards were placed in a legally untenable position -- faced with an executive order in conflict with the state constitution and state law," the school boards said in their statement Friday. "That conflict has also put the health and safety of our students and staff at risk, as the Omicron variant continues to affect Virginia localities. We are confident that the court will soon come to the right decision to resolve this pressing matter."
“Local school boards, not the governor, have responsibility and authority for supervision of schools,” John Cafferky, the lawyer for the school boards that sued, said in court Wednesday.
Deputy Attorney Gen. Steven Popps argued Youngkin has broad powers to modify rules during the COVID-19 emergency, just as former Gov. Ralph Northam often did.
“Executive Order 2 was and is a lawful exercise of the emergency powers granted to the governor,” Popps said in court Wednesday.
News4 sends breaking news stories by email. Go here to sign up to get breaking news alerts in your inbox.
The school boards’ lawyer argued that Youngkin’s executive order endangers children and teachers, especially those who have health conditions.
The governor’s lawyer said students coming to school without masks are being harmed by being isolated from other students or even suspended.
People on both sides of the case have said an appeal is likely to be filed.
Stay with NBC Washington for more details on this developing story.
